Chewy vs PetSmart Dog Food Prices — Who Wins in 2025?
We run the numbers daily on 50+ brands. Here's where to buy each one for less.
The Short Answer
Chewy Wins On…
Premium brands with auto-ship, large bag sizes, and brands exclusive to online. Auto-ship beats PetSmart sticker price ~70% of the time.
PetSmart Wins On…
In-store-exclusive promotions, Treats+ loyalty stacking, brands like Royal Canin Vet Diets, and same-day pickup when you need food today.
Head-to-Head: 2025 Price Comparison (30-lb bag)
Chewy prices include the auto-ship discount. PetSmart prices reflect standard retail without Treats+ points.
| Brand | Chewy Auto-Ship | PetSmart Retail | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Purina Pro Plan | $82 | $95 | Chewy 🏆 |
| Hill's Science Diet | $90 | $102 | Chewy 🏆 |
| Blue Buffalo Life | $72 | $78 | Chewy 🏆 |
| Royal Canin Adult | $85 | $88 | Chewy 🏆 |
| Iams Adult Chicken | $38 | $42 | Chewy 🏆 |
| Purina Beneful | $35 | $33 | PetSmart 🏆 |
| Taste of the Wild | $58 | $64 | Chewy 🏆 |
| Merrick Grain-Free | $68 | $75 | Chewy 🏆 |
| Nutro Natural Choice | $55 | $52 | PetSmart 🏆 |
| Wellness Core | $80 | $88 | Chewy 🏆 |
Prices approximate. Use DogFood.bot for today's live comparison.
Chewy: The Full Picture
Auto-Ship: The Game Changer
Chewy's auto-ship is the single biggest price lever in pet food retail. First order: up to 35% off on select items. Ongoing orders: 5–15% off. Choose your frequency (every 2–16 weeks) and pause or cancel anytime. For a $100 bag of premium kibble, that's $15–$35 saved per order.
What Chewy Does Better
- Widest online catalog — thousands of SKUs not in physical stores
- Free 1–2 day shipping on orders over $49
- 24/7 customer service with actual representatives
- Free vet chat for basic questions
- Prescription food and medications (pharmacy)
- Generous return policy — even on opened bags
Chewy Limitations
- No physical store pickup — delivery only
- Auto-ship discounts vary by brand and change frequently
- Not always cheapest on budget or store brands
PetSmart: The Full Picture
Treats+ Loyalty Program
PetSmart's Treats+ earns 8 points per dollar spent, redeemable for discounts. Members also receive monthly coupons, birthday discounts for pets, and early sale access. Stacked with an active promotion, effective discounts can reach 25–30%.
What PetSmart Does Better
- Same-day in-store pickup and curbside
- Exclusive brands and veterinary diets (Royal Canin Vet formulas)
- In-store nutrition consultations
- Grooming and veterinary clinic access in-store
PetSmart Limitations
- Higher base prices than Chewy on most national brands
- Loyalty program benefits take time to accumulate
- No auto-ship program competitive with Chewy's
The Hybrid Strategy: Use Both
🧠 The Winning Approach: Set up auto-ship on Chewy for your primary dry food. Use PetSmart for in-store emergencies, exclusive brands, and when Treats+ stacks with a sale to beat Chewy's price. Check DogFood.bot monthly to make sure you're still on the best deal.
See Today's Price Side-by-Side
Enter your brand and size — we'll show you who's cheapest right now.
🐾 Compare Chewy vs PetSmart